CALIFORNIA FOCUS
FOR RELEASE: TUESDAY, APRIL 3, 2018 OR THEREAFTER
FOR RELEASE: TUESDAY, APRIL 3, 2018 OR THEREAFTER
BY THOMAS D. ELIAS
“A CAMPAIGN FILLED WITH UNREALISTIC PROMISES”
“A CAMPAIGN FILLED WITH UNREALISTIC PROMISES”
It’s
early in the election season, barely past the filing deadline, more than two
months before the June primary election and more than six months before
November, when voters will elect the next governor of California.
But
it’s already clear that fundamental pledges made by the leading candidates in
all the early public polls have been essentially unrealistic.
The
two most ambitious promises made so far both came from Democrats who have now
backed off one and are clinging to hope that they can somehow make the other
work.
Those
promises: A single-payer Medicare-style health plan for all Californians
mimicking the federal Medicare coverage available to everyone over 65. And a
pledge to add 3.5 million housing units in all parts of the state by 2025, or
about half a million living spaces per year for the next seven years.
Even
Democrats and health care advocates pushing hardest for single-payer – a key
plank in the state Democratic Party’s platform – have come to see it as
unrealistic just now. So they’re backing a package of bills in the Legislature
that aims to expand health insurance coverage beyond what the federal
Affordable Care Act – Obamacare – has already done.
Meanwhile,
there has never been one year – even during the era of California’s headiest
growth – when 500,000 housing units were built in this state, let alone seven
consecutive years. It’s not even certain there would be enough available wood,
concrete and other building materials.
It’s
not so much that the candidates are backing away from ideas they’ve supported;
rather, reality has set in and they’re realizing they must be more incremental.
Take
the current leader in all polls, Democratic Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom, the former
mayor of San Francisco best known for his order allowing America’s first
same-sex marriages. Newsom lists San Francisco’s universal health plan as one
of his top achievements, and still wants statewide single-payer.
But
when more than 50 labor unions, ethnic and health-oriented groups in mid-March
endorsed a package of bills expanding the state’s Obamacare plan, Covered
California, to include undocumented immigrants while also lowering premiums via
subsidies drawn from other state funds, Newsom was quick to endorse.
He
called the new, scaled-back plan “a step in the right direction, with the
potential to move closer to our ultimate goal…single-payer.”
Of
course, the new realism bears out criticisms by other candidates like former
Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and state Treasurer John Chiang, who
pointed out – among other items – that Medicare premiums now paid by
Californians which would be essential to funding a state single-payer plan are
extremely unlikely to be available to state government so long as Donald Trump
remains president.
The
candidates have not yet backed off their extremely optimistic housing goals.
Said
a Newsom aide, “Gavin is committed to creating the incentives to do 3.5 million
units. Conditions demand it. We can’t just sit by in our massive housing
crisis, which is not only over homelessness, but also affordability.”
Republicans
have also made unrealistic efforts, most notably San Diego businessman John
Cox, who tied his candidacy to an initiative expanding the state Legislature to
12,000 members. That measure never got off the ground because it had almost no
popular support.
The
campaign has also brought out some decidedly Trumpian comments from Democrats,
as when Villaraigosa said he was “ascendant” at a time when he still trailed
Newsom in every survey. Chiang, running third among Democrats in public polls,
made even more Trump-like statements on social media.
“@realDonaldTrump
& DC @GOP have made it their mission to put affordable healthcare out of
reach for American families,” he tweeted. “CA should move toward #SinglePayer
& I’m the only one who can balance a budget to get it done.”
In
a Feb. 14 tweet, he also pronounced himself the “Most Accomplished Man in
California.”
Both
tweets aroused memories of Trump telling the 2016 Republican National Convention
that only he could “make American great again.”
All
of which makes this a very challenging primary election season for California
voters, who must sift through myriad claims and promises and then decide who
can actually run the nation’s largest state government in a way that combines
idealism and realism to solve tough problems.
-30-
Email
Thomas Elias at tdelias@aol.com. His book, "The Burzynski Breakthrough,
The Most Promising Cancer Treatment and the Government’s Campaign to Squelch It,"
is now available in a soft cover fourth edition. For more Elias columns, visit www.californiafocus.net
No comments:
Post a Comment